Monday, 30 July 2012

A hidden marketplace: Private tutoring in the former socialist bloc

A hidden marketplace: Private tutoring in the former socialist bloc Image by Antony Bennison via Flickr

The collapse of the socialist bloc in 1989 was accompanied by a severe economic decline. This resulted in the decrease of education spending in most countries of Southeast/Central Europe and the former Soviet Union.

Twenty years later, the global financial crisis has dealt another major blow to the educational systems of the former socialist bloc. As public expenditure on education declined, the share of costs borne by individuals and families has exponentially grown in most countries of the region.

The new private costs of education to households include:

(1) Formal fees in private schools, universities, and non-compulsory levels of education

(2) Community and household contributions towards the financing of local schools (such as school maintenance and repairs)

(3) Payments for textbooks, school meals, and extracurricular activities

(4) Payments for complementary items (such as clothing, shoes, and transportation)

(5) Informal payments to public schools. This includes payments for private tutoring, which have generally remained invisible to education policymakers

Revealing statistics

Over 60 per cent of a surveyed student population received some type of private tutoring in the last year of secondary school. And more than 80 per cent of students in Azerbaijan and Georgia attending private tutoring lessons.* That’s according to cross-national studies of private tutoring in 12 countries of Southeast/Central Europe and the former Soviet Union.

Among students, the scope and intensity of private tutoring is generally associated with the perceived deterioration of education quality in public schools. In particular, students believe that they cannot acquire the necessary knowledge and skills in public schools. So they turn to private tutoring to increase their educational advantage. They believe that private tutoring will help them to better prepare for school-leaving and/or university entrance examinations. In Azerbaijan and Georgia, some high school students reportedly stop going to school during the last couple of months before university entrance examinations, and instead attend private tutoring lessons.

Mixed views
The unprecedented rise of private tutoring has mixed reactions.

On the one hand, many parents view private tutoring as an effective way for children and youth to adapt to the new sociopolitical realities and cope with post-socialist system changes. Responding to students’ needs more efficiently and effectively, private tutoring is perceived as an important supplement to the public education system, which has been slow to embrace change.

On the other hand, however, private tutoring has contributed to exacerbating social inequities. Because of high costs, it is generally unaffordable to students from rural areas and lower socioeconomic families. This impacts negatively on their chances of school success and social mobility.

Need to understand impact

Given that private tutoring remains largely invisible to policymakers, it is critical to better understand its relationship to public schooling and its implications for social equity. As long as public education remains underfunded and students believe that public education does not provide quality education, the demand for private tutoring will continue to grow and socioeconomic inequities will further escalate.

* Silova, I., Budiene, V., and Bray, M. (Eds.). (2006). Education in a Hidden Marketplace: Monitoring of Private Tutoring. New York: Open Society Institute, 2006). 

http://www.soros.org/sites/default/files/hidden_20070216.pdf

* Silova, I. (Ed.). (2009). Private Supplementary Tutoring in Central Asia: New Opportunities and Burdens. Paris: UNESCO IIEP, 2009. Combined, the surveys from the two studies targeted almost 12,000 respondents, corresponding to 8,713 respondents from the first study and 3,101 respondents from the second one. 

http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0018/001851/185116e.pdf

Last modified on Tuesday, 01 October 2013
Iveta Silova

Iveta Silova is an Associate Professor and Director of Comparative and International Education program at the College of Education, Lehigh University. Her research and publications cover a range of issues critical to understanding post-socialist education transformation processes in the context of globalization, including gender equity trends in Eastern/Central Europe and Central Asia, minority/multicultural education policies in the former Soviet Union, as well as the scope, nature, and implications of private tutoring in a cross-national perspective. She is the co-editor (with Noah W. Sobe) of a quarterly peer-reviewed journal "European Education: Issues and Studies."

Other blog posts

Reforms and cuts, the prelude of a reconversion of Spanish universities

on Friday, 01 June 2012

Cuts and erosion of education are not something new in Spain, a country where public expenditure in higher education is only 1.1%. Regions finance more than 90% of education, and those in the hands of conservative parties have reduced education funding since 2009. The situation rapidly deteriorated during 2011, when 15 of the 17 regions were governed by conservative parties. The worst cuts have been inflicted on universities whose budgets have been reduced by 12% on average, with decreases up…

Read more...

The global learning crisis is costing 129 billion USD per year

Written by
on Wednesday, 29 January 2014

  Worldwide, millions of children are failing to learn the basics. Children who already face disadvantage – girls, the poor, the disabled those in rural areas, are being hit the hardest.   We reveal the scale of this global learning crisis in the 2013/4 Education for All Global Monitoring Report, launched today in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.   The Report, Teaching and learning: Achieving quality for all, shows that the learning crisis is costing governments $129 billion a year: 10 per…

Read more...

The uncertain future of American public education

Written by
on Thursday, 19 July 2012

While academics and policymakers are debating whether education could be preserved as a public good in the aftermath of the global economic crisis, the business world has a different take on the issue. For private equity investors in the United States, education is first and foremost a lucrative investment opportunity. It is merely a commodity that can be opportunely bought and sold in the growing educational marketplace. On 26 July, the Capital Roundtable (America's leading conference company for the middle-market…

Read more...

A generation scarred by the cuts of austerity

Written by
on Wednesday, 13 June 2012

At the risk of sounding nostalgic, some things it seems really were better in the good old days. Depending upon our age, we might quibble about the music or the fashion styles, but there's one thing we can all probably agree on – the job prospects facing young people today are worse than ever. The International Labour Organization, in its Global Employment Trends for Youth 2012, says an estimated 75 million people between the ages of 15 and 24 will…

Read more...
blog archive

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter the (*) required information where indicated. HTML code is not allowed.