Tuesday, 09 April 2013

Towards meaningful solidarity

Towards meaningful solidarity Image via Flickr by BlueRobot

I became a teacher because I enjoy helping young people learn. I saw teaching as a way to “make a difference” in the world. But at this moment in history, teachers face opponents who are doing great harm, to children, schools, and our profession, harm that we cannot impede solely through our role in classrooms. The rich and powerful, who exploit their stunning wealth to control media and government, use lofty-sounding slogans about “students first” and “making schools work” to mask an agenda that increases social, political, and economic inequality.

 

We are in a life-and-death struggle for our profession and professional lives.  To slow this global project, let alone win any significant economic or professional victory, we need to rethink our unions’ goals and organizational structures.  Teachers unions, especially in the global north, have viewed themselves as service organizations.  Instead we should function more like social movements, seeing our members’ well-being as inextricably connected to broad struggles for social, economic and political justice. Consider how  Honduran teachers led the movement to protect political freedom when the nation’s duly-elected president was ousted by the military. We can learn from Chicago teachers how to re-appropriate the language and leadership of campaigns to give all children quality education  so as to embed our professional and economic demands in a vision of schooling that parents and community can embrace.

 

Sometimes I am told that an international transformation of education could not exist without our knowing more about it, and that what I am describing sounds like a conspiracy. Most definitely not!  Conspiracies are, by definition, secret.  The global project to destroy education as a publicly-funded cornerstone of democracy has been quite public for more than four decades - if one looked for evidence in the right places - reports from the World Bank, journals of finance, and prospectuses for corporations penetrating the “educational market,” and research. For wealthy, powerful elites, public expenditures on educating workers beyond the skill level needed for low paying jobs seems a foolish waste of money. Their assumptions are revealed in the outcomes of their reforms rather than their rhetoric, which often calls for increased levels of education. To understand their goals, we need to look beyond  employer protestations that they want workers with more education to the reality that most jobs being created require no more than an 8th grade education. It is for this reason that elites driving educational reform aim to produce only a handful of people need to acquire the sophisticated thinking and skills to manage and control the world’s productive resources. Minimally educated workers need only minimally educated teachers.  Despite governments’ talk of making their nations more competitive economically by ratcheting up standards, the impact of reforms make their aims clear. They can use standardized tests to superintend the lowered expectations for educational outcomes  they want for the vast majority of students.  Therefore a well-educated (and well-paid) teaching force is a wasteful expenditure.  

 

They aim to make public education a “free market" open to entrepreneurs; create a revolving door of minimally-trained teachers; reduce the curriculum to basic math and literacy content that workers will need to compete for low-paid jobs; control teachers, students, and future citizens with standardized testing; and weaken public oversight of education by breaking up school systems, replacing them with privately operated schools and networks.

 

Teachers and their unions are the biggest impediment to these goals being realized, which is why teachers unions have been attacked so viciously.  Teachers unions have slowed the project, although they have been too weak to halt it. Our opponents have exploited historic inequalities in education, hijacking the language associated with movements for social justice and using it to mask their real agenda of increased profits and control of the work force.  Claiming they are “Making services work for poor people,” they impose reforms (as a quid pro quid for economic aid) that actually worsen educational outcomes and strip nations of the right to determine how schooling should shape their society.

 

Do we have adequate resources to become involved in other struggles?  In fact, allying our unions with parents and community in their struggles repays us doubly. We involve members who have not heretofore been active and show ourselves trusted allies, developing legitimacy among parents and community who are suspicious of unions.

 

I often hear teachers complain “Where is the union?” They think officers and staff are the union, delivering services to them.  In actuality, our unions’ power resides in our members’ involvement, but members will not be active if they feel disempowered.  To bring democracy to the schools, our unions themselves must be models of democracy.

The Chicago Teachers Union stunned the media and the Mayor when its representative assembly insisted on taking the terms of the tentative settlement back to members, to determine whether to end the strike.  As one Chicago teacher told a reporter, the strike was  “an amazing display of democracy.”  "It is a wonderful lesson for children and adults alike. I'm honored that we are all sticking together. We all want what is fair. We want to make sure everyone is treated fairly, just like I teach my children."

 

Exactly. Just like we teach - or should teach - our students. Teachers unions must practice democracy, from the school site right up through the international level. That means rejecting how the World Bank sets education goals. That means supporting activists, unions and communities as they tell us what help they need to resist neo-liberal education policies. “Intercambio,” a collaboration of the British Columbia Teachers Federation and a network of Latin American teachers unions, the IDEA Network (Initiative for Democratic Education in the Americas), illustrates one way to work towards meaningful solidarity across borders. 

Last modified on Tuesday, 01 October 2013
Lois Weiner

Lois Weiner is a professor of education at New Jersey City University and a member of AFT Local  #1839. She co-edited with Mary Compton a collection of essays, the “The Global Assault on Teaching, Teachers, and Their Unions: Stories for Resistance.”  Her new book, “The Future of Our Schools: Teachers Unions and Social Justice” describes how teachers unions can become social movements and why they need to make this change, now, to save public education and the profession.

Other blog posts

What's Wrong With Low-Cost Private Schools for the Poor?

Written by
on Tuesday, 28 May 2013

Right now, there is considerable attention being focused on a growing phenomenon in a number of developing countries -- private primary schools that charge relatively low fees.  They are described in miraculous terms, as private schools, once the bastion of the well-to-do, are now reaching disadvantaged families and thus have become essential to the provision of quality primary school for all, as envisioned in the Millennium Development Goals and the Education for All compact.  As the economists say, poor people…

Read more...

Short Termism vs. sustainable development

Written by
on Wednesday, 27 June 2012

Sustainable development is a sensible framework for looking at the system. It represents a fundamental shift in analysis from the “Washington Consensus”. The idea of examining economic, social, and environmental issues together as three, interdependent pillars of development was a sharp break with the idea that the market was king and that everything else should respond and adapt to it. The ambulances were to be dispatched to retrieve the bodies of the market’s victims from the economic battlefield. And the…

Read more...

Reforms and cuts, the prelude of a reconversion of Spanish universities

on Friday, 01 June 2012

Cuts and erosion of education are not something new in Spain, a country where public expenditure in higher education is only 1.1%. Regions finance more than 90% of education, and those in the hands of conservative parties have reduced education funding since 2009. The situation rapidly deteriorated during 2011, when 15 of the 17 regions were governed by conservative parties. The worst cuts have been inflicted on universities whose budgets have been reduced by 12% on average, with decreases up…

Read more...

Why well-trained and effective teachers are central to tackling the global learning and skills crisis

Written by
on Thursday, 26 September 2013

What is the situation? The right to education that stimulates active learning and inspires imaginations can only be a reality when the transformative power of education is fully realised, however too many children and young people - especially the disadvantaged - are leaving school without learning anything of value.   There is consistent evidence that teachers are the most important school-based factor in determining learning outcomes, second only to what children bring to school. Yet globally there remains a marked…

Read more...
blog archive

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter the (*) required information where indicated. HTML code is not allowed.